For an all-around balance of page capacity and everyday flexibility, I’d start with the CAGIE A5 Bullet Dot Grid Journal; the LEUCHTTURM1917 Bullet Journal Edition 2 suits buyers who want a purpose-built journal, while Mr. Pen’s set adds useful accessories for getting started. The main tradeoffs are paper and binding quality, how many pages you want in one notebook, and whether you need one durable journal or several low-commitment notebooks. A thick journal can last longer between replacements, but may feel bulky; multipacks offer room to experiment, though each notebook has fewer pages. Read on for how the 12 options compare and which one fits your planning style.
Get the little things that make your day delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Key Takeaways
- CAGIE’s 320 pages make it the capacity pick for keeping long-running plans in one A5 notebook, though that many pages add bulk.
- LEUCHTTURM1917’s Bullet Journal Edition 2 is the most purpose-built choice in this group; its two color options serve the same format, so choose by preference rather than assuming one has different features.
- Multipacks serve different habits: Chiisong offers 10 notebooks and XYark offers 12, while PAGELYST supplies four 200-page notebooks for buyers who want more pages per book.
- Mr. Pen’s 160-page set is a practical beginner choice when included accessories matter; PAPERAGE’s similarly sized options are simpler alternatives for buyers who want a single notebook.
- Page counts and formats vary widely—from XYark’s 60-page books to CAGIE’s 320-page journal—so match capacity to how often you plan to migrate notes or replace a notebook.
| PAPERAGE Dotted Journal Notebook, Blush, 160 Pages |  | Best Overall | Dimensions: 5.6 x 8 inches | Page count: 160 | Paper weight: 100 gsm | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Mr. Pen A5 Dotted Journal Notebook Set, 160 Pages |  | Best for Beginners | Notebook size: A5 (5.7 x 8.4 inches) | Pages: 160 dotted pages | Included items: One hardcover journal, one retractable pen, 50 sticky tabs | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| &And Per Se A5 Dotted Journal, Green |  | Best for Page Navigation | Format: A5 | Dimensions: 5.7 x 8 inches | Pages: 160 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Ohuhu A5 Dotted Bullet Journal Notebook, 126 Pages |  | Best for Marker Users | Size: A5 | Pages: 126 numbered pages | Paper weight: 195 gsm | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| CAGIE A5 Bullet Dot Grid Journal, 320 Pages, Green |  | Best for Long-Term Journaling | Format: A5 | Pages: 320 total: 314 dotted pages and 6 contents pages | Paper weight: 100 gsm | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Chiisong A5 Dotted Notebooks, 10 Pack |  | Best for Shared Planning | Quantity: 10 notebooks | Size: A5, 5.7 × 8.3 inches | Pages: 160 per notebook | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Paperage Dotted Journal Notebook, Black, Medium (5.6″ x 8″), 160 Pages, 100 GSM Thick Paper – Hardcover |  | Best for a Dependable Everyday Journal | Color: Black | Size: 5.6 × 8 inches | Pages: 160 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| PAGELYST A5 Dotted Journal Notebooks, 200 Pages, 4-Pack |  | Best Multi-Notebook Kit for Layout Makers | Pack quantity: 4 notebooks | Size: A5, 5.7 × 8.3 inches | Pages: 200 per notebook | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| XYark 12-Pack A5 Dot Grid Notebooks, 60 Pages Each |  | Best for Short-Term Projects | Quantity: 12 notebooks | Size: A5, 8.3 × 5.5 inches | Pages: 60 per notebook | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| RETTACY A5 Dotted Journal Notebook, 192 Pages |  | Best Single-Journal Accessory Set | Brand: RETTACY | Size: A5, 5.7 × 8.3 inches | Pages: 192 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| LEUCHTTURM1917 Bullet Journal Edition 2 Medium A5 Hardcover Green |  | Best for Guided Setup | Size: A5 (Medium) | Cover: Hardcover | Color: Green | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Leuchtturm1917 Bullet Journal Edition 2, A5, Turquoise |  | Best for Color Choice | Brand: Leuchtturm1917 | Edition: Bullet Journal Edition 2 | Paper size: A5 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| bullet journal | Cover | Pages | Binding | Size |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PAPERAGE Dotted Journal Notebo | Water-resistant vegan leather | — | Thread-bound, lay-flat | — |
| Mr. Pen A5 Dotted Journal Note | Hardcover | 160 dotted pages | — | — |
| &And Per Se A5 Dotted Journal | PU leather hardcover | 160 | — | — |
| Ohuhu A5 Dotted Bullet Journal | Faux leather hardcover | 126 numbered pages | 180° lay-flat | A5 |
| CAGIE A5 Bullet Dot Grid Journ | Waterproof vegan leather hardcover | 320 total: 314 dotted pages and 6 contents pages | Lays flat at 180° | — |
| Chiisong A5 Dotted Notebooks | PU leather hardcover | 160 per notebook | Unspecified | A5, 5.7 × 8.3 inches |
| Paperage Dotted Journal Notebo | Water-resistant vegan leather hardcover | 160 | Thread-bound, lay-flat design | 5.6 × 8 inches |
| PAGELYST A5 Dotted Journal Not | Water-resistant leather hardcover | 200 per notebook | — | A5, 5.7 × 8.3 inches |
| XYark 12-Pack A5 Dot Grid Note | Soft cover | 60 per notebook | Unspecified | A5, 8.3 × 5.5 inches |
| RETTACY A5 Dotted Journal Note | Leather hardcover | 192 | Hardcover | A5, 5.7 × 8.3 inches |
| LEUCHTTURM1917 Bullet Journal | Hardcover | 206 numbered pages | — | A5 (Medium) |
| Leuchtturm1917 Bullet Journal | — | 204 numbered pages | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
PAPERAGE Dotted Journal Notebook, Blush, 160 Pages
For a balanced everyday bullet journal, this PAPERAGE Blush pairs a manageable 5.6-by-8-inch format with 100 gsm dotted paper and a hardcover that resists water. Its thread-bound construction is designed to lie flat, making two-page spreads easier to fill than in a notebook that resists opening. The pocket, elastic closure, ribbon, and sticker labels cover practical organizing needs without requiring a separate starter kit. Compared with the Mr. Pen A5 Set, it offers specified heavier paper and a water-resistant cover, while Mr. Pen includes a pen and sticky tabs. The tradeoff is that PAPERAGE lists only 160 pages and does not say which pens avoid ghosting or bleed-through, so heavy marker users have less certainty than with the Ohuhu.
Pros:- 100 gsm acid-free paper is thicker than standard notebook paper and is designed to reduce show-through.
- Thread-bound lay-flat construction makes writing across a spread more comfortable.
- Water-resistant vegan leather cover helps protect the journal during everyday carrying.
- Expandable pocket, ribbon, elastic closure, and sticker labels support organization.
Cons:- The listing does not specify which pens or markers the paper can handle without bleed-through.
- At 160 pages, it will need replacing sooner than the 320-page CAGIE for frequent long-form journaling.
Best for: Daily journalers who want a portable, lay-flat notebook with thicker paper and built-in storage.
Not ideal for: Marker-heavy artists who need a stated paper performance range or the Ohuhu’s 195 gsm stock.
- Dimensions:5.6 x 8 inches
- Page count:160
- Paper weight:100 gsm
- Paper:Acid-free, light ivory
- Page style:Dotted
- Cover:Water-resistant vegan leather
- Binding:Thread-bound, lay-flat
- Extras:Expandable inner pocket, sticker labels, ribbon bookmark, elastic closure
- Color:Blush
Our verdict“Choose this PAPERAGE if you want a versatile, well-equipped daily bullet journal and do not need heavyweight marker paper.”
Mr. Pen A5 Dotted Journal Notebook Set, 160 Pages
The Mr. Pen A5 set lowers the setup burden for someone starting a bullet journal: a retractable pen and 50 sticky tabs arrive with the notebook, so basic logging and indexing can begin right away. Its 5.7-by-8.4-inch size gives a little more page area than the smaller PAPERAGE Blush, though it may take up more room in a small bag. The dotted pages suit calendars, trackers, and free-form notes, while the pocket, ribbon, and elastic closure keep loose items together. Compared with the &And Per Se, this pick supplies more immediately useful organization accessories, but it does not list a paper weight or claim special ink resistance. That makes it a simpler starter choice than the heavyweight Ohuhu, with less assurance for marker-based layouts.
Pros:- Includes a retractable pen and 50 sticky tabs for starting an index and marking sections.
- A5 format offers a compact but useful writing area for weekly spreads and trackers.
- Elastic closure, ribbon bookmark, and inner pocket help keep the journal organized.
- Dot-grid pages accommodate both structured layouts and free-form notes.
Cons:- Only one notebook is included, so it does not provide backups or separate journals for different projects.
- Paper weight and ink performance are not specified, limiting confidence for heavier pens and markers.
Best for: New bullet journalers who want a single notebook plus basic tools for labeling and organizing pages.
Not ideal for: People who need multiple notebooks in one purchase or want specified thick paper for brush pens and markers.
- Notebook size:A5 (5.7 x 8.4 inches)
- Pages:160 dotted pages
- Included items:One hardcover journal, one retractable pen, 50 sticky tabs
- Page style:Dotted
- Cover:Hardcover
- Organization features:Elastic closure, ribbon bookmark, inner pocket
Our verdict“Pick Mr. Pen if you are beginning a bullet journal and value included tabs and a pen over documented paper performance.”
&And Per Se A5 Dotted Journal, Green
For bullet journalers who move between a monthly plan, active trackers, and notes, the &And Per Se makes page navigation its clearest advantage: two bookmarks let you keep separate sections marked without adding tabs. The three sticker sheets offer decoration and labeling options, while the expandable pocket holds loose pages. Its 100 gsm paper and 180-degree lay-flat design put it in the same broad practical class as the PAPERAGE Blush, though PAPERAGE specifies thread binding and a water-resistant cover. Compared with the included pen and tabs in the Mr. Pen A5 Set, this notebook favors built-in markers for two-page tracking over ready-to-use writing tools. The paper is claimed to work with most pens, not all, and the binding type is unspecified, so marker-heavy users may prefer the Ohuhu.
Pros:- Two bookmarks make it easy to keep multiple bullet journal sections open at once.
- 100 gsm paper is designed for smooth writing with most pens.
- 180-degree lay-flat design supports spreads across both pages.
- Expandable back pocket and three sticker sheets help with storage and section labeling.
Cons:- The listing does not identify the binding type.
- The paper is described as suitable for most pens, leaving uncertainty for some inks and markers.
- At 160 pages, it has less capacity than the 320-page CAGIE.
Best for: Organized journalers who keep several active sections and want two bookmarks plus labeling stickers.
Not ideal for: Users who want a specified binding type or plan layouts around inks that may bleed through ordinary paper.
- Format:A5
- Dimensions:5.7 x 8 inches
- Pages:160
- Paper weight:100 gsm
- Ruling:Dotted
- Cover:PU leather hardcover
- Special features:180° lay-flat design, two bookmarks, expandable back pocket
- Included accessories:Three sticker sheets
- Color:Green
Our verdict“Choose &And Per Se if you regularly switch between journal sections and want two built-in bookmarks.”
Ohuhu A5 Dotted Bullet Journal Notebook, 126 Pages
The Ohuhu A5 is the specialist in this group for layouts built with heavy ink: its 195 gsm bleedproof paper is substantially thicker than the 100 gsm stock in the PAPERAGE, &And Per Se, and CAGIE notebooks. That can make brush lettering, color-coded trackers, and marker illustrations more practical without sacrificing the reverse side to ink. Numbered pages and a starter guide also help users build an index and structured system quickly. The tradeoff is capacity: it has 126 numbered pages, far fewer than the CAGIE’s 314 dotted pages, so a frequent journaler may fill it sooner. Its heavyweight paper also changes the feel and bulk of the notebook, making it less suited to someone who wants a slim everyday carry. Choose this for ink tolerance, not maximum page count.
Pros:- 195 gsm bleedproof paper is designed for marker-heavy layouts, including alcohol markers.
- Numbered pages make indexing and returning to trackers easier.
- 180-degree lay-flat binding supports two-page spreads and drawing.
- Starter guide, storage pocket, ribbon, and elastic closure add practical setup help.
Cons:- 126 pages provide much less writing capacity than the 160-page options and the 320-page CAGIE.
- Heavyweight paper makes it a less compact choice than lighter-paper A5 journals.
Best for: Bullet journal artists and planners who use alcohol markers, brush pens, or layered color and want numbered pages.
Not ideal for: Frequent long-form journalers seeking high page capacity or a lighter, slimmer notebook.
- Size:A5
- Pages:126 numbered pages
- Paper weight:195 gsm
- Paper features:Bleedproof, acid-free, FSC-certified
- Grid:Light-gray dot grid
- Cover:Faux leather hardcover
- Binding:180° lay-flat
- Extras:Elastic closure, ribbon bookmark, back storage pocket, starter guide
- Edge finish:Holographic gilded edges
Our verdict“Choose the Ohuhu if marker performance matters more to your bullet journal than page count or slim portability.”
CAGIE A5 Bullet Dot Grid Journal, 320 Pages, Green
If your bullet journal holds months of logs, collections, and notes, the CAGIE offers the most listed writing capacity here: 314 dotted pages plus six contents pages. That makes it a better fit for keeping a long-running system in one volume than the Ohuhu, whose 126 pages serve marker users but run out sooner. Its 100 gsm acid-free paper, 180-degree lay-flat binding, pen holder, pocket, ribbon, and elastic closure cover the everyday needs of a structured journal. Compared with the PAPERAGE Blush, it provides much more page room and a pen holder, while PAPERAGE gives a more compact 5.6-by-8-inch footprint. One caveat is that the title says 320 pages while the breakdown accounts for 314 dotted pages and six contents pages; marker performance is also not specified.
Pros:- 314 dotted pages plus six contents pages provide substantial room for ongoing logs and collections.
- 100 gsm acid-free paper is designed to help reduce ink bleed-through.
- 180-degree lay-flat binding supports writing across both pages.
- Pen holder, storage pocket, ribbon bookmark, and elastic closure support daily organization.
Cons:- The title’s 320-page count is presented differently from the detailed breakdown of 314 dotted and six contents pages.
- The 100 gsm paper is not specified for alcohol markers or other heavy inks.
- A full 320-page A5 notebook is less suited to buyers who want a compact, lightweight journal.
Best for: People who maintain detailed daily logs, recurring trackers, and collections and want them together in one A5 volume.
Not ideal for: Users who prioritize marker-tested paper or want a smaller journal that is easier to carry.
- Format:A5
- Pages:320 total: 314 dotted pages and 6 contents pages
- Paper weight:100 gsm
- Paper type:Acid-free, 5 mm dot grid
- Cover:Waterproof vegan leather hardcover
- Binding:Lays flat at 180°
- Features:Storage pocket, ribbon bookmark, elastic closure, pen holder
- Color:Green
Our verdict“Choose CAGIE if keeping a long stretch of bullet journal logs in one notebook matters more than compactness or marker-specific paper.”
Chiisong A5 Dotted Notebooks, 10 Pack
The 10-notebook set makes sense for households, classrooms, or teams that want separate bullet journals without buying notebooks one at a time. Five colors help assign a journal to each person or project, while the A5 dot grid supports flexible trackers and weekly spreads. Each notebook has 160 pages of 100 GSM acid-free paper, plus a hardcover, elastic closure, and inner pocket. Compared with the XYark 12-Pack, Chiisong offers substantially more pages per notebook and a sturdier listed cover; XYark supplies more individual books but has only 60 pages each. The tradeoff is uncertainty: the binding type is unspecified, and this set lacks listed bookmarks or a pen holder. It suits buyers who value quantity and color coding over a fully documented, single-journal setup.
Pros:- Ten notebooks make it easy to separate journals by person or project.
- Five colors provide a practical color-coding system.
- Each book has 160 pages of 100 GSM acid-free dot grid paper.
- Hardcovers, elastic closures, and inner pockets add basic protection and storage.
Cons:- Binding type is unspecified, so lay-flat behavior is unknown.
- No ribbon bookmark or pen holder is listed.
- A ten-book set may be more than a solo journal keeper needs.
Best for: Families, students, or project groups who want color-coded A5 bullet journals with enough pages for ongoing plans.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a confirmed lay-flat binding, bookmark, or pen holder for a single daily-carry journal.
- Quantity:10 notebooks
- Size:A5, 5.7 × 8.3 inches
- Pages:160 per notebook
- Paper:100 GSM, acid-free dot grid
- Cover:PU leather hardcover
- Colors:Green, yellow, pink, purple, and blue; two of each
- Features:Elastic closure and inner pocket
- Binding:Unspecified
Our verdict“Choose Chiisong if you want a color-coded supply of full-length A5 bullet journals for several people or projects.”
Paperage Dotted Journal Notebook, Black, Medium (5.6″ x 8″), 160 Pages, 100 GSM Thick Paper – Hardcover
Paperage earns a place for buyers who want the core bullet-journal features in one straightforward notebook. Its thread-bound construction lays flat, which makes two-page spreads easier to use than in a journal with unspecified binding, such as the Chiisong A5 set. The 160 pages of 100 GSM acid-free ivory paper offer room for regular logs and planning, while the elastic closure, ribbon bookmark, and expandable pocket keep loose notes organized. Rounded corners and a water-resistant vegan-leather cover suit frequent carrying. Compared with the accessory-heavy RETTACY A5 Dotted Journal, Paperage has fewer listed tools: no pen holder or stencils. That keeps the setup simple, but writers who want a pen attached or more layout aids should look elsewhere.
Pros:- Thread-bound design lays flat for spreads and comfortable writing.
- 100 GSM acid-free paper is designed to resist bleed-through with most pens and markers.
- Elastic closure, ribbon bookmark, and expandable pocket support everyday organization.
- Water-resistant vegan-leather hardcover protects the pages during carrying.
Cons:- No built-in pen loop or holder is listed.
- At 160 pages, it offers less room than the PAGELYST 200-page notebooks.
- The black cover offers less color-coding choice than multi-color sets.
Best for: Daily journal keepers who want a lay-flat A5-style notebook with a bookmark and pocket for portable planning.
Not ideal for: Journalers who want a built-in pen holder, stencils, or more pages than a 160-page notebook provides.
- Color:Black
- Size:5.6 × 8 inches
- Pages:160
- Paper:100 GSM, acid-free ivory
- Cover:Water-resistant vegan leather hardcover
- Binding:Thread-bound, lay-flat design
- Features:Elastic closure, ribbon bookmark, expandable inner pocket, sticker labels
Our verdict“Pick Paperage for a no-fuss daily bullet journal where lay-flat binding and a ribbon bookmark matter most.”
PAGELYST A5 Dotted Journal Notebooks, 200 Pages, 4-Pack
PAGELYST is the most layout-ready multi-pack here: each 200-page A5 notebook includes two ribbon bookmarks, a pen holder, an expandable pocket, and stencil cards. That combination helps a bullet-journal keeper build trackers and spreads without assembling accessories separately. Its stated 180-degree lay-flat design is also a useful advantage over the Chiisong and XYark sets, whose binding details are unknown. The four-book count gives less volume than Chiisong’s ten notebooks, but each PAGELYST journal has more pages than Chiisong’s 160-page books and XYark’s 60-page ones. The tradeoff is that the paper is described as resisting bleed-through with most pens, so heavy markers may still show through. Buyers wanting one substantial journal may prefer the single-book RETTACY instead.
Pros:- Four notebooks each provide 200 pages for extended planning.
- 180-degree lay-flat design supports writing across a spread.
- Pen holder, pocket, and two bookmarks keep tools and pages organized.
- Four stencil cards offer ready-made aids for trackers and layouts.
Cons:- Only four notebooks are included, fewer than the Chiisong and XYark sets.
- Paper resistance is specified for most pens, leaving uncertainty with heavier tools.
- Multiple accessories may be unnecessary for a minimalist journaling setup.
Best for: Bullet journalers who make frequent custom spreads and want several notebooks with built-in layout and storage accessories.
Not ideal for: Minimalist users who want one journal, or artists who rely on heavy markers and need guaranteed no show-through.
- Pack quantity:4 notebooks
- Size:A5, 5.7 × 8.3 inches
- Pages:200 per notebook
- Paper:Acid-free, 100 GSM
- Dot spacing:5 mm
- Cover:Water-resistant leather hardcover
- Features:180-degree lay-flat design, pen holder, elastic closure, expandable inner pocket, two ribbon bookmarks
- Included accessories:4 stencil cards
Our verdict“Choose PAGELYST if you want a multi-book bullet-journaling kit with generous page counts and ready-made layout tools.”
XYark 12-Pack A5 Dot Grid Notebooks, 60 Pages Each
XYark’s defining advantage is its 12-book variety: assorted colors make it easy to assign a thin notebook to each class, project, or short planning cycle. At 60 pages apiece, these are better suited to temporary logs or focused projects than to a year-round bullet journal. That short format can be useful if you like starting fresh often, but it means more frequent notebook changes than with the Chiisong 160-page set or PAGELYST’s 200-page books. The soft covers and compact A5 dimensions favor carrying a spare notebook, though they provide less structure than hardcover options. Paper is described as thick enough to help prevent bleed-through, but its GSM is not specified; binding is also unknown, so page behavior is harder to judge.
Pros:- Twelve assorted-color notebooks make project separation simple.
- A5 format is compact enough to carry alongside other materials.
- Dotted light-cream paper works for writing, planning, and creative layouts.
- Short page count can suit focused logs that are meant to end quickly.
Cons:- Each notebook has only 60 pages, so ongoing journals will need frequent replacement.
- Binding type is unspecified, leaving lay-flat behavior unclear.
- Paper weight is not provided, making pen and marker performance harder to predict.
- Soft covers offer less protection than the Chiisong and Paperage hardcovers.
Best for: Students and organizers who want many lightweight notebooks for short assignments, rotating projects, or separate topic logs.
Not ideal for: Anyone building a long-running bullet journal who wants a sturdy hardcover, known paper weight, or confirmed lay-flat binding.
- Quantity:12 notebooks
- Size:A5, 8.3 × 5.5 inches
- Pages:60 per notebook
- Sheets:30 per notebook
- Ruling:Dotted
- Paper color:Light cream
- Cover:Soft cover
- Colors:12 assorted colors
- Binding:Unspecified
Our verdict“Pick XYark for a supply of slim, color-coded notebooks for short projects rather than one continuous bullet journal.”
RETTACY A5 Dotted Journal Notebook, 192 Pages
RETTACY suits someone who wants one capable bullet journal with layout aids included. Its 192 pages of 100 GSM acid-free paper provide more room than Paperage’s 160-page notebook, while the 180-degree lay-flat design supports spreads and two-page trackers. A pen holder, two ribbon bookmarks, inner pocket, and two stencils make the single-book setup more self-contained than the Paperage Dotted Journal, which has a bookmark and pocket but no listed pen loop or stencils. The A5 size keeps it portable, though it gives less writing area than larger formats. This is a one-notebook purchase, so it lacks the color-coded quantity of Chiisong or PAGELYST multi-packs. The leather hardcover and accessories add utility, but may be more than a minimalist needs.
Pros:- 192 pages offer more room than Paperage’s 160-page journal.
- 180-degree lay-flat design makes full spreads easier to write across.
- Pen holder, two bookmarks, inner pocket, and two stencils support an all-in-one setup.
- 100 GSM acid-free paper is designed to resist ghosting and bleed-through.
Cons:- A5 pages may feel cramped for users who prefer larger spreads.
- Single notebook provides no multi-book color-coding option.
- Included accessories may be unnecessary for a minimalist journal keeper.
Best for: A5 journal keepers who want a single, well-equipped notebook for planning, trackers, sketching, and everyday notes.
Not ideal for: Writers who need larger pages, multiple color-coded journals, or a bare-bones notebook without accessories.
- Brand:RETTACY
- Size:A5, 5.7 × 8.3 inches
- Pages:192
- Paper:100 GSM, acid-free, dotted
- Cover:Leather hardcover
- Binding:Hardcover
- Features:180-degree lay-flat design, pen holder, elastic closure, two ribbon bookmarks, inner pocket
- Included accessories:2 journaling stencils
- Unit count:1
Our verdict“Choose RETTACY if you want one portable A5 bullet journal with more pages and layout accessories than a basic notebook provides.”
LEUCHTTURM1917 Bullet Journal Edition 2 Medium A5 Hardcover Green
The Bullet Journal Edition 2 is the more guided choice for someone who wants a notebook set up around the bullet journaling method. Its built-in key, index, and future log give new users a starting structure, while the numbered dot-grid pages and subtle markers help keep lists and monthly spreads aligned. Compared with the CAGIE A5 Bullet Dot Grid Journal, which offers more pages, this Leuchtturm1917 gives up capacity for a more purpose-built planning kit and 120 GSM paper. The wider margins leave room for notes or decoration, and the ruler and stickers support setup. The tradeoff is its 206-page limit; frequent journalers may fill it sooner than they would a higher-capacity notebook.
Pros:- Built-in key, index, and future log provide a ready-made planning framework
- 120 GSM sustainably sourced paper offers a substantial writing surface
- Numbered dot-grid pages with subtle markers help organize consistent spreads
- Ruler, pocket guide, and monthly-log stickers support setup
Cons:- 206 pages may not last long for users who journal daily
- The built-in planning approach may be unnecessary for people who prefer a blank notebook
Best for: New bullet journalers who want planning prompts and layout tools in one A5 hardcover notebook
Not ideal for: Frequent journalers who need a high page count for long-running logs or extensive daily entries
- Size:A5 (Medium)
- Cover:Hardcover
- Color:Green
- Pages:206 numbered pages
- Paper weight:120 GSM
- Grid:Dot grid with subtle markers
- Included features:Bullet key, index, future log, pocket guide, ruler, and sticker sheet
Our verdict“Choose this edition if you want a guided bullet journal with useful setup tools and can work within 206 pages.”
Leuchtturm1917 Bullet Journal Edition 2, A5, Turquoise
This turquoise version keeps the Bullet Journal Edition 2 setup in a bright cover color, pairing an index, future log, and bullet key with numbered dot-grid pages. Like the green LEUCHTTURM1917 Edition 2, it uses 120 GSM paper, subtle markers, and wider margins, so the choice between them is mainly about color and the listed page count: this one has 204 pages, two fewer than the green version. The pocket guide doubles as a ruler, and the monthly-log stickers offer a quick way to label spreads. Compared with the PAGELYST A5 Dotted Journal 4-Pack, it is a more fully equipped single journal, though the pack provides several notebooks for rotation. Its limited 204-page capacity may not suit long-running or especially detailed journals.
Pros:- Index, future log, and bullet key provide a clear starting structure
- 120 GSM sustainably sourced paper supports a substantial writing feel
- Numbered dotted pages include subtle markers and wider margins
- Pocket guide doubles as a ruler, with stickers included for monthly logs
Cons:- 204 pages may be limiting for frequent or extensive journaling
- The specialized setup and accessories may be unnecessary for users who want a plain dot-grid notebook
Best for: Bullet journalers who want the Edition 2 planning tools and prefer a turquoise A5 hardcover option
Not ideal for: People who need a large page supply or prefer buying several simpler notebooks for different projects
- Brand:Leuchtturm1917
- Edition:Bullet Journal Edition 2
- Paper size:A5
- Dimensions:6 × 8 in
- Pages:204 numbered pages
- Paper weight:120 GSM
- Ruling:Dotted
- Color:Turquoise
- Included accessories:Pocket guide/ruler and sticker sheet
Our verdict“Pick the turquoise Edition 2 if its color and guided planning kit appeal more than having the extra two pages in the green version.”
How We Picked
I compared these bullet journals on the factors that shape daily use: dot-grid format, stated page count, A5 or medium sizing, hardcover construction where specified, and whether the product is a single journal or a multipack. I also considered how each format serves common routines, such as keeping a year of plans together, trying bullet journaling without committing to a large notebook, or maintaining separate work and personal logs. I treated specific construction and paper claims as useful only where the product details provide them; the available details do not support a head-to-head paper performance ranking across all 12.
The ranking favors journals with a clear fit for sustained bullet journaling, then options that offer useful flexibility or a distinct entry point. That puts CAGIE’s high page count and LEUCHTTURM1917’s dedicated edition near the top, while multipacks rank by their per-notebook capacity and likely use case. Similar PAPERAGE variants and the two LEUCHTTURM1917 colors are distinguished by stated size, color, or product format rather than assumed differences in quality. Buyers who prioritize portability, specific paper behavior, or accessory details should check the full product specifications before choosing.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Bullet Journals
I’d choose a bullet journal by the way I expect to use it over time, not by page count alone. These broader tradeoffs can help narrow the options before you settle on a format.
How Many Pages Will You Actually Fill?
Estimate how many spreads you make in a typical week, then think about how often you want to start a fresh notebook. A high-capacity journal can keep an index, future plans, and ongoing collections together, but it becomes heavier as you add pages. Shorter notebooks make it easier to archive a finished period or try a new layout without carrying a thick book. A common mistake is buying the largest page count because it seems like the most useful option, then finding that the journal is cumbersome to carry. Choose capacity around your routine and tolerance for switching notebooks.
Match the Format to Where You Write
A5 and medium notebooks leave room for weekly layouts while remaining easier to carry than larger desk-focused formats. Still, page dimensions alone don’t tell you how comfortable a book will feel in a bag or on a small table. If you plan mostly at home, a thicker journal may be easy to manage; if you write during commutes, a slim notebook can be less intrusive. Check the closed dimensions and weight when the product lists them, especially for multipacks you might carry together. Think about your writing space as well as your storage space.
Treat Paper Claims as a Compatibility Check
Paper weight and finish affect how pens, markers, and highlighters behave, but a single specification does not guarantee that every ink will suit your style. If you use fountain pens or wet markers, look for product-specific information about bleed-through and ghosting, and seek a return policy that gives you room to check. Buyers who write with ballpoint or pencil may have fewer paper demands than those building colorful spreads. A frequent mistake is assuming that any dotted journal supports heavy marker use. Pick paper based on your actual tools, and test a new pen near the back before filling the book.
Decide Whether Accessories or Multipacks Help
An accessory set can reduce the number of supplies a beginner needs to gather, but only if the included items match the way they plan to journal. Multipacks make sense for separate projects, school terms, work logs, or testing different layouts; they can also create clutter if you prefer one continuous archive. Compare the page count of each notebook as well as the total number of books. A large pack of thin notebooks is not equivalent to a few thick journals when you want long-running collections. Buy the bundle that solves a real organization problem.
Pay More for Features You Will Keep Using
A purpose-built journal or more substantial construction can be worthwhile if you keep indexes and collections active over a long period. That added commitment has less value if you often abandon layouts, change systems, or prefer to archive notebooks frequently. New users may benefit more from a flexible format that lets them discover their habits before choosing a long-term journal. For a gift, consider whether the recipient values a specialized bullet-journal format or would rather have a simple notebook they can adapt. Spend according to how much the construction and intended format matter to your routine.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I choose a high-page-count journal or a multipack?
Choose a high-page-count book if you want long-running plans and collections together in one place. A multipack works better when you separate subjects, use a fresh notebook for each project, or want to try different planning styles. Compare pages per notebook rather than focusing only on the pack’s total. Also think about whether you want to carry one thick journal or several slim ones.
Is the LEUCHTTURM1917 Bullet Journal Edition 2 worth choosing over a standard dotted notebook?
It may suit you if you want a journal specifically presented for bullet journaling and prefer a more deliberate, long-term setup. A standard dotted notebook can be the more flexible choice if you are still experimenting with layouts or want a simpler format. Compare the features listed for the exact edition and color you’re considering, since the two options here are both Edition 2 models. Your writing tools and desired page capacity may matter more than the label.
What should a beginner prioritize in a first bullet journal?
Prioritize a format you can comfortably carry and enough pages to practice without feeling obliged to preserve every spread. An accessory set such as Mr. Pen’s may be convenient if its contents suit your needs, while a straightforward single notebook leaves you free to choose your own supplies. Avoid making elaborate layouts a requirement for getting started; a simple index and a few regular logs are enough to learn what works. You can choose a more specialized journal once your routine becomes clearer.
Can I use a dotted journal with markers or fountain pens?
That depends on the specific paper and the ink, since the product names and page counts alone do not establish how each combination will perform. Look for paper-weight and bleed-through details in the listing, especially if you use wetter inks or markers. Try a sample mark on a back page before building a spread, and allow ink to dry before closing the notebook. If paper behavior is a deciding factor, seek a clear return option before committing.
Which option makes sense if I want to keep work and personal plans separate?
A multipack can make separation straightforward: Chiisong and XYark offer many individual notebooks, while PAGELYST pairs a smaller pack with more pages per book. If you need long-running collections for each area, consider whether their per-notebook page counts will last long enough. One larger journal with clear sections is another approach if you prefer a single index and archive. Choose based on whether switching between books or keeping everything together feels easier to maintain.
Conclusion
For a best overall balance of capacity and a familiar A5 format, I’d choose CAGIE, provided its added thickness suits how you carry a journal. Best value for multiple projects depends on the format you need: PAGELYST gives you four 200-page books, while Chiisong and XYark provide more notebooks for shorter or separate logs. For a best premium, purpose-built option, I’d pick LEUCHTTURM1917 Bullet Journal Edition 2; for a beginner who wants supplies in one purchase, Mr. Pen’s set is the clearest fit. Choose PAPERAGE or another single 160-page option if you want a straightforward notebook, and choose a multipack when keeping subjects apart matters more than maintaining one continuous journal.
